Tuesday, July 29, 2014

The 18th Century

The 18th century

The Enlightenment On the whole the 1700s were less interested in poetry or literarure though than philosophy and politics. The flamboyant baroque that dominated the preceding century turns into a simplified decoration mainly used for decoration: the Rococo.

As the century progresses, sobriety becomes the canon. Science breaks new ground and becomes the center of interest in the name of pragmatism and progress. Philosophy is still used with the meaning of "love of knowledge", but the knowledge coming from the exact sciences, as maths and physics. 

Literature is no longer a leader, but becomes a means to an end, it is made to serve causes as campaigns for democracy or social justice and scientific articles are sometimes put into verse. Science seems divorced from the realm of humanities and poetry which can only be ancillary to more important causes. 


Literature as a conduit for science High-brow literature is scientific in the modern sense of the world. For the first times economics, sociology, history, architecture, physics, biology, medicine, agriculture and even the arts and crafts are grouped by the philosophes in collective efforts, as encyclopedic dictionaries (the Encyclopédie sparks a cultural revolution and even attracts the interest of monarchs and princes. 


Les lumières, or the Enlightenment was a sort of pre-positivism mostly inspired by the intellectual environment of late 17th century England and the so-called libertines or free-thinkers and blooms in France in the 18th. From there it spread to most European countries, even touching Prussia and Russia. 


Lombard Philosophes say no to the Crusca Inspired by France and England, many countries start liberal reforms inspired to the principles of tolerance, equality and fiscal justice, though rusults vary depending on the state we are looking at. Alessandro and Pietro Verri even founded Il Caffé (1764-1766), a magazine about contemporary culture where they advocated the cause for Italy's unification and the enlightened ideas of the philosophes. 


Many Italian states were foreign dominions: some, like Lombardia and Veneto (then forming one state), had been annexed to the Austrian Empire. It is only natural that the Verri and many more intellectuals looked to France's culture as a model, and praised French, regarded as a modern language as opposed to the Italian, considered immature because it was still anchored to Bembo's literary canon. 


It is with such ideas in mind that Alessandro Verri published in the Caffé his Rinunzia davanti al notaio al Vocabolario della Crusca ('Refusal of the Crusca Dictionary before a notary').in 1764. To this environment belonged Beccaria, and the younger Manzoni. 


The prestige of France may explain to some extent why the literary debate about the italian language stalls and the French language penetrates so widely in the grammar and lexicon. There seems to be no consensus about what Italian should sound like, whether and how it should be reformed and by whom., says Migliorini. Florence declines as a cultural hub, and a new school founded in 1690 in Rome, the Arcadia, go as far as mocking the Florentines, accusing the Crusca of sticking to an old-fashioned language that has lost its grasp with the present. 


Italy divided over the Crusca The Romans despised Florentine for being full of gross and vulgar words, labeling it unfit to play a pivotal role on the linguistic scene. The conservative North and the South insisted on maintaining the old Florentine diction of the 14th century based on Petrarch, Dante, and Boccaccio (volgare illustre) without proposing those much-needed reforms or changes to update a language that is growing old-fashioned. 


One happy exception is Milan, where the Verris and other readers of the Caffé were were more inclined to experiment. French as the perfect linguistic model But the prestige of French meant that even many of the inherent qualities of the Italian language were regarded as defects.


There were many loan words and expressions from France, and at this point the Italian language seems to be influenced by the stricter word order of the French phrase (more similar to the English), against the traditional Italian model which reflects the looser word-order of Latin embraced by Dante, Petrarch and Boccaccio. Milan's intellectuals were generally against tradition and much attracted by the turn of phrase of the scientific literature that came from France or Britain. 


The fact that French texts were widely read and esteemed generated such words as Madama [fr. Madame, en. madam], madamosella [fr. mademoiselle, en. young lady], bidè [fr. bidet], baionetta [fr.baïonnette], mitraglia [mitrailleuse, en. machine-gun], bloccare [fr. bloquer, en. block], picchetto [fr. piquet, en.picket], marionetta [fr. marionette, [en. puppet], rondò [rondeau], minuetto [minuet], oboe [hautbois], cretino [crétin], abile [fr.habile, en.able], autorizzare [fr.authoriser], concorrenza [fr.concurrance, en. competition], guadagnare [al gioco: gagner, en. win], interessante [fr. intéressant, en. interesting], intraprendente [fr. entreprenant, en. enterprising], intrapresa [fr. entreprise, en. enterprise], liquore [fr. liqueur], manifattura [fr.manufacture], pubblico [fr. public], rapporto [fr. rapport, en. relationship], toccante [fr. touchant, en. touching], travaglio [fr. travail, en. work]. Or expressions as bel mondo [fr. beau monde, en. high society], colpo d'occhio [fr. coup d'œïl, en. look], presenza di spirito [fr. présence d'ésprit, en. presence of spirit], sangue freddo [fr. sang-froid, en. courage], far la corte [faire la cour, en. seek after], dar carta bianca [donner carte blanche, en. give carte blanche], a misura che [fr. à mesure que, en. by, the more...], toilette or toletta. 


Changes in syntax are not just apparent in the re-arrangement of the sentence after the French word-order (Mario non fa che lavorare [Mario ne fait que travailler, en. Mario only works], though the native 'Mario lavora soltanto' is not discarded). They affect phrases in the excessive use of the partitive (as in più di amicizia [< fr. plus d'amitié, en. more friendship] or troppo di generosità [trop de générosité, en. too much generosity]. 


Such phrases were used quite often, but this was a timely fashion: they were scrapped in the following century when the prestige of France declined in the eyes of the intellectuals. If a lesser attention to the classics and literature implied less control, it also meant there could be room for the long-banned imports from Italian dialects that had so far despised by the purists. 


Since most dialects are morphologically and phonetically compatible with Florentine, introducing non-Florentine or popular Tuscan words words allowed for more technical words and colloquialisms to enter the Italian language. The French Revolution and the Empire The enlightened ideals from France and Italy would soon provide the fuel for the American, and a few years later, the French Revolutions, and from there the new spirit of freedom would spread to the rest of the world. 


But when the French Revolution turned into imperialism and French troops under Napoleon conquered Italy, the disillusionment about France caused a rejection of the French language, which in the minds of many could be no longer associated with freedom and democracy. 


Such reaction seemed to suggest that national sentiment had been re-awakened in Italy, though it is fair to say that Napoleon's tyranny stirred mixed feelings among the people who met his armies: corvés and feudal injustice were abolished by the French, and goods could circulate freely: no more taxes to cross bridges or get in or out of the city. 


These were freedoms that the Italians experimented to their advantage, and welcomed. Butit was not the freedom that they had been promised, So, not even when the old foreign powers were re-enstated in the old continent following the Congress of Vienna (1815) could the march towards unification be stopped: consequently, the Italian language continued to make headway as the language of one Italy, though amongst impediments. 


Most Italians were still raised in their local dialect and many of those who could go to school were usually raised with French. But they were more and more determined in learning the national language. Such was the case of a new talented Lombard who became the author of the first great novel ever written in Italian: I promessi sposi (The Betrothed) by Alessandro Manzoni was the book that helped many to learn the language, while pleading for the cause of Italian unification.

The 17th Century

Baroque, Counter-Reformation and Science The English-speaking world has a pivotal year in the history of its language: 1611, when the Authorised Version of the Holy Bible, also known as the King James' Bible was finished. A year later another great work reached was published in Italy: it was The Vocabolario degli Accademici della Crusca. The purpose of the first Italian dictionary was to establish a norm and catalogue old and new words. The Accademia della Crusca had been founded in 1583 in Florence with an aim to protect the budding Italian language and encourage Italians how to use it correctly. 
Its motto is taken from Petrarch: "Il più bel fior ne coglie'' means, in English, "it picks of the most beautiful flower", that is, it (the Crusca Academy) selects and preserves the best of the Italian language. Curiously, the Sala delle Pale (Lit. "The Hall of Shuffles"), where the board meet, has chairs whose backs look like big shuffles. 


Their shape hints at the act of "separating the wheat from the chaff". After undergoing a big revision in 1623, the 1691 edition made the Vocabolario the biggest dictionary ever compiled in the Western World. Indeed, the 1600s were not without accomplishments. 


This was the Age of Milton, who also contributed to the development of Italian studies on his visit to Italy before the English Civil War. It was also the time when a Florentine scientist invented the telescope. By watching the stars, Galileo Galilei (1564-1642) proved that Keptler's theory that the earth revolved around the sun. 

Visionaries under Inquisition Galileo's findings discredited Ptolomeus's theories endorsed for centuries by the Catholic Church. Dante himself in his Commedia had put the earth at the centre of the universe, surrounded by invisible spheres, each them carring a planet, all of them enclosed by the empiraeum, a bright sphere containing the Paradise. 


Philosopher Giordano Bruno had, too, intruduced new, revolutionary concepts in the later 1500s, assuming there could be intelligent creatures living on other planets similar to the earth. But his unorthodox theories, adding to his homosexuality attracted the attention of the Inquisition. 

Spain ruled over most of Italy: it was the worst of times to be a visionary. In fact, the century opens with an ominous warning to free-thinkers: Bruno is burnt at the stake in the spring of 1600 in the Campo dei Fiori. A few years later, Galileo would be subjected to a long trial by the Inquisition for having published his Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems (Dialogo sopra i due massimi sistemi del mondo, 1632) under the auspices of the pope but widely condemned by the Jesuits. 

His work, basically an illustration of the heliocentric theory and the introduction of the modern trial-and error system of scientific enquiry, was not just a giant milestone for science. It was one of the major books written in the Italian language. Galileo's contribuition to scientific prose His contribution to Italian prose is significant, especially at a time when scientific treatises were still being written in Latin. 


Unfortunately, this was the book as earned him a trial by the Inquisition (1633) and a life sentence (after he had recanted all his theories), commuted to house arrests in Florence thanks to the help of influential friends. Such a sentence must have been hard upon him, who was already old and ill when he wrote the Dialogue. He died shortly after, being even denied medical care for his hernia and having lost his sight, in 1642. 


Galilei is widely remembered for his pioneering work in the field of science, but his contribution to modern Italian is often overlooked. His scientific background contributed a style which though quite faithful to Bembo's standard couple clarity of expression with many new technical words then widely ignored for not belonging in literature or poetry. 


Here is an excerpt about sunspots, in which it is proven, against Ptolomoeus's theory, that the sun rotates around its axis: 


Fu il primo scopritore ed osservatore dele macchie solari, siccome di tutte l'altre novità celesti, il nostro Academico Linceo; e queste scopers'egli l'anno 1610, trovandosi ancora alla lettura delle Matematiche nello Studio di Padova, e quivi ed in Venezia ne parlò con diversi, de i quali alcuni vivono ancora: ed un anno doppo le fece vedere in Roma a molti Signori, come egli asserisce nella prima delle sue Lettere al Sig. Marco Velsero, Duumviro d'Augusta. Esso fu il primo che, contro alle opinioni de i troppo timidi e troppo gelosi dell'inalterabilità del cielo, affermò tali macchie esser materie che in tempi brevi si producevano e si dissolvevano; che, quanto al luogo, erano contigue al corpo del Sole, e che intorno a quello si rigiravano, o vero, portate dall'istesso globo solare, che in sé stesso circa il proprio centro nello spazio quasi di un mese si rivolgesse, finivano loro conversioni: il qual moto giudicò sul principio farsi dal Sole intorno ad un asse eretto al piano dell'eclittica, atteso che gli archi descritti da esse macchie sopra il disco del Sole apparivano all'occhio nostro linee rette ed al piano dell'eclittica parallele (...) 

(Galileo, Dialogo, III, 438) 

tr.


Linceo, our Academician, was the first to discover and observe sunspots, as well as all the other novelties of the heavens, and these he discovered in the year 1610, while he was a lecturer in mathematics in the Faculty of Padua, and it was here as well as in Venice that he discussed the issue with a number of people, some of whom are still living: and, one year later, he showed them to several gentlemen, as he states in the first of his letters to Mister Marco Velsero, Augusta's Duumvir. He was the first who, against the opinions of those who were too timid and jealous of the immutableness of the heavens, said that such spots were substances that were no sooner made than dissolved; that, as far as their location was concerned, belonged to the body of the sun and revolved around it, viz carried by the very globe of sun which turned around its center in about a month and that ended up revolving around it: which motion he first thought to be caused by the sun turning around an axis at right angles in respect to the plane of the ecliptic, giving that the arcs produced by such spots on the sun disk looked to us like straight lines parallel to the plane of the ecliptic (...) (Galileo, Dialogues, III, 438) "


Galileo trusted the vernacular with his far-reaching and sophisticated science. Linguistically, he has knowingly coupled the heritage from his native Tuscany with the "polished" manners of literary tradition...with the "mechanic" lexicon, also by endorsing such clarity...to those who did not know latin" (Salinari). 


Orthodoxy strikes at the Italian language One of the most noticeable characters of the 17th century is that, unlike the Renaissance, it is a century of paradox: one the one side, the orthodox (purist in language and moralistic in literature), on the other, the rebels who strove to did the opposite and shock traditional society, disregarding the linguistic and moral establishment, from Marino's scholarly, but sensual and exotic verse to much vernacular literature whose writers used words from dialect or just vulgar language if only to shock and dazzle the audience. 


The academic environment of Counter-Reformation was hostile to innovation, and not just in what might appear to endanger Catholic dogmas. This conservatism in linguistics, implied dictating taste rather than discuss it, to catologue words rather than create new one. Less than three century had passed from the lively, stimulating discussions about the future of Italian and the creative work of those who had literally invented a new language.


The attitude of humanists in the 1600s is quite different and transpires in almost all aspects of Italian life. The linguists seem more interested in stockpiling old words rather than keeping the language fresh and up-to-date, while a large group of Baroque writers disseminate a host of new words that the establishment refuses to admit they even exist. 


Most of the intellectual élite refused to acknowledge it was imperative to add new technical words (Galileo was a remarkable exception ) to the Dictionary though science, then rapidly evolving, needed them badly. It is something that has not only been observed by Migliorini et al. but noted by Manzoni in his masterpiece novel set in the early 1600s, for which he did a lot of research about the 1600s. 


The Betrothed (see the speech of the notorious attorney Azzecca-Garbugli, asked to defend Renzo's case, but in fact evading most of the his problems with his most obscure and rhethorical language. There are other such characters who express themselves in that manner, and are those who actually slow down Renzo's efforts to rescue Lucia from her kidnapper.) 


The Age of Baroque This is, however, a great century for the visual arts: baroque, San Peter's Cathedral and Bernini's architecture being one of the biggest accomplishments. Baroque literature, however, though linguistically original and innovative in a number of ways, does not either produce any great works able to rival those of the past centuries. Rather, it is replete of bad imitations of Dante and Petrarch. 


The word manierismo, "mannerism" dates appropriately to the final decades of the Renaissance and anticipates some of the fashions which Baroque will take to excess. Writers who try their best to pump new blood into the drying literary vein often produce texts that are either unintelligible for their abundant rhetoric or so full of extravagant embellishments that it takes the big Vocabolario and a scholarly knowledge to get a grasp of the meaning. 


Where science is not directly concerned, form overwhelms in weight content itself and, like Baroque decoration, is often more imposing than the underlying architecture, the statues, the arches that should be the center of attention. Baroque in the visual arts and literature Today, when an Italian refers to an obscure text, he or she may say it is concettoso. 


And it is the use of 'concetti', inherited from medieval literature, that abounds in Baroque works, and to a good extent, in Metaphysical Poetry. When used moderately, such devices may add value to a poem. But many Baroque writers abused them, making their text so obscure and their speeches so long-winded looking like riddles, being so full of imagery and metaphors as to suggest a game of mirrors or even the deliberate use of cryptic language. 


The masque is a constant in Baroque theatre, and script writers enjoy creating characters who change in shape and identity, such as mythological figures often playing on sexual ambiguity or double identity. Such ambiguity also reflects in language and style. 


Baroque literature can juggle with words as much as Baroque decorations distort geometry and volumes: as you walk past the long columnade in St. Peter's Square and head for the obelisk you get the feeling that outer rows of the round square slide magically on each other to dwindle in one row when you get to the monument. You see them moving but they do not. 


Michelangelo's Moses looks like he is turning his torso because of the optic effects applied to the
marble. A similar philosophy was applied to language, with mixed results. While the Crusca's stand on language was uncompromising and close to Galileo's scientific prose, many writers rebelled not just to academic, but classical conventions, calling for absolute freedom in the name of originality and creativeness. 


As a result, their period may take a zig-zag pattern, moving from one image to another without any apparent link between sentences, the phrase may be overburdened with adjectves to impress the reader. Oxymorons and hyperboles may be compared to the optic illusions of Bernini in Saint Peter's Square. 


Gianbattista Marino, one of the greatest poets of the age, exemplifies the new taste in his Adone, a narrative poem in octaves. I have italicised the concetti and the Baroque imagery in both the original and my translation: 


Sotto questa fontana a chiome sciolte 

su 'l bel fitto meriggio aveano usanza 
le Napee del bel loco in un cerchio accolte 
vaghe caròle esercitare in danza. 
Com'Ila in lor le luci ebbe rivolte, 
D'infiammarle tra l'acque ebbe possanza, 
onde nel vivo e lucido cristallo 
rotto nel mezzo abbandonaro il ballo 
Come la stella nel mar divelta cade 
da l'azzurro seren del ciel estivo, 
o qual strisciando per oblique strade 
fende il notturno vel raggio festivo, 
così la rara e singolar beltade 
rapita in giù dentro quel gorgo vivo, 
precipitando tra le chiare linfe 
trovossi in braccio alle gelate Ninfe. 

Translation: 


Under this fountain, their hair loose 

In a thick shade the Nymphs did use 
Of that beautiful place in a circle gathered 
Carols sublime sing on their dances. 
As Ila her lights to them had pointed 
She could enflame them out of water 
So that that living and bright crystal 
Once broken in its middle they stopped dancing 
Like a star falling in the sea 
From the azure serene of summer sky 
Or, when crawling along its oblique way 
Breaks the night's shadow the festive ray 
So that rare and striking beauty 
Once ravished down that living funnel 
Having fallen down those clear fluids 
Found herself embraced by the cool symphs 

In the Baroque everything is changing and moving: curiously, the love of masks, stage-machines, lighting effects and ballets of bizarre and mythological figures are the flip-side of the same religious art that inspired Bernini and Michelangelo. 


The words of Marino dazzle the mind much as much as St. Peter's columnade dazzles the eye: its great power lies in that it can hardly pinned down by reason. Rather, it enchants and persuades without it. It can produce great religious prose: Donne, as some Italian preachers, created powerful sermons that still move and enthrall readers. 


Comedians were particularly successful in turning traditional rhetoric figures as calembours, oxymorons, assonances, chiasms to achieve grotesque effects. A notorius device recurrent in satirists is tonodidactics, consisting of taking a common sentence and replacing some its morphemes: as to make it sound like the original though the spelling tells quite another thing: the producer made a film > the producer met a Phil Baroque's dazzling language If the extragavant use of concetti could not produce high-brow literature, Baroque writers could nonetheless pride themselves on inventing some remarkably odd words. 


They were always looking for the strangest espressions to surprise and shock their audiences, and ransacked the dialects when they could not find any good Italian ones. Many more neologisms have come to us from the arts and crafts as well, though not officially acknowledged by scholars: regulations and instruction manuals for artisans were also widely printed in Italian, and only technical terms in current use had to be included in glossaries so that artisans and engineers could earn their living. 


Obviouly this met with the purists opposition, but it could not be helped. The Crusca's conservatism The Accademia della Crusca expunged those technical terms from its dictionary. As a result, non-natives coming to Italy on business often complained about not being able to find in the Dizionario any explanation for the commonest words Italians used in the workplace. 


Some of these were only added much later, when this conservative attitude no longer prevailed: the ideal purpose of the Dictionary was to present its readers with a range of words recommended for academic debate or polite usage and the grammar rules to follow in that context. 


Despite the Crusca's conservatism, Tuscany was the most open to change: more resistance came from other states: the Vatican, for eg. continued to discourage the use of the Italian though virtually no one spoke Latin except during the mass. 


It would be unwise, however, to infer that the ban received unanimous support even in the highest hierarchies of the Church. Spelling reform The 1600s witnesses the introduction of some spelling changes that had been proposed one century earlier as the graphic distinction between U and V. 


One would no longer write sentences as: l'vomo vero è vno solo, but "l'uomo vero è uno solo". No longer would writers use Xs in words (compare: exemplo with essempio, esempio), It. e and ed instead of et, and -zi /-zzi were used instead of previous -ti or -tti (compare gratie with grazie, actione with azione). 


Such changes were to remain in present-day Italian. t and c replaced th and ch in Greek words, in which the h, only etymological, not sounded, disappeared (compare theatro with teatro, christiano with cristiano). Milton, Italian Scholar Most would not expect to find John Milton in the
History of Italian. 


But as he could rival or even oustrip his Italian contemporaries in the art of sonnet-writing I will not just call him an English, but an Italian poet. He spoke Italian, Latin, Greek, and Hebrew with great ease, and it is virtually impossible find a blemish in his Italian Songs and Sonnets he left us.
 

He was befriended by the great Florentines of the time, who soon recognised his literary genius. In Florence, Milton was welcomed as their peer.by the Accademia degli Svogliati, where he stopped for some time on his tour of continental Europe in 1638-9. 

That was the time when he also visited Venice, Siena, Naples and the Vatican, probably paying a visit to Galileo then at house arrests at Arcetri (Florence). But his stay was unfortunately short, as the Puritans' campaign against James II soon recalled him to London. 


The Renaissance was known almost a century later in many European countries, and having playwrights as Shakespeare, Jonson, and of poets like Donne and Milton working in the early 1600s may explains why Elizabethan and Jacobean Literature looks more to Mannerism and
Baroque than the Italian Renaissance of the mid 1550s. 


Let us have a look at Sonnet 3: 


Qual in colle aspro,  al imbrunir di sera 

L'avezza giovinetta pastorella 
Va bagnando l'herbetta strana e bella 
Che mal si spande a disusata spera 
Fuor di sua natia alma primavera, 
Cosi Amor meco insù la lingua snella 
Desta il fior novo de strania favella, 
Mentre io di te, vezzosamente altera, 
Canto, dal mio buon popol non inteso 
E'l bel Tamigi cangio col bel Arno. 
Amor lo volse, ed io a l'altrui peso 
Seppi ch'Amor cosa mai volse indarno. 
Deh! foss'il mio cuor lento e'l duro seno 
A chi pianta dal ciel si buon terreno. 

Which you can read in William Cowper's translation: 


As on a hill-top rude, when closing day Imbrowns the scene, some past'ral maiden fair Waters a lovely foreign plant with care, That scarcely can its tender bud display Borne from its native genial airs away, So, on my tongue these accents new and rare Are flow'rs exotic, which Love waters there, While thus, o sweetly scornful! I essay Thy praise in verse to British ears unknown, And Thames exchange for Arno's fair domain; So Love has will'd, and oftimes Love has shown That what He wills he never wills in vain. Oh that this hard and steril breast might be To Him who plants from heav'n, a soil as free.

The 16th Century: the Renaissance

The 16th Century: the Renaissance

Bembo's New Standard
 
When a linguistic unification is achieved, political consolidation often follows. But the Italians, who were on the whole, whether willingly or not, divided by foreign powers who extended their political influence throughout the peninsula, would or could not settle their differences and the feuds between powerful local families usually ended in violence. Feelings ran high even between jealous siblings whom enemies knew how to pit against one other. 

Because of such partisanism, even linguistic consolidation could not achieved without difficulties, on account of the same rivalries that divided the courts politically. Though scholars like Castiglione and Trissino, quoting Dante, defended the dignity of the language spoken at court, claiming that a national standard should be the equal sum of regional varieties rather than predominantly Florentine and praised the dignity of Italian. 


Castiglione and Trissino's school was aptly called the Courtisan Tradition and is explained in the former's masterpiece, Il Cortegiano (1528), soon to be followed by Giangiorgio Trissino's Castellano (1529) which supported Castiglione's theories. 


The theory earned a certain reputation, but regional jealousies could hardly lead to a consensus. A compromise between dialects was all but impossible as each prince pretended to impose his own over the others, while the Florentines, given their literary tradition would not accept 'corruptions' from the outside. 


And yet not not a few Italians felt a common language was necessary, not least merchants who had to compile glossaries of different dialects even for minor business trips within Italy. Hoping to reach a solution, Machiavelli defended the rural or vernacular Florentine as opposed to the high standard of Dante, Boccaccio and Petrarch. 


Machiavelli's Rural Florentine: the Municipal Tradition 

Italian seems to develop after the success of purist view, (Dante, Petrarch and Boccaccio'a literary language should be the canon). Such party is probably responsible for the coinage of many new words of classical origin while those from dialect (spoken Florentine) sometimes take new meanings.


Machiavelli's position is openly municipal: he puts more value in the colloquial Florentine spoken at his time and excludes any literary or archaic language from the past. In the appendix to his Clizia, one of his comedies, he expounds his ideas in an imaginary conversation between him and Dante. 


Here, il Sommo Poeta is made to sound like a snob and hypocrite, since machiavelli accuses him of having perverted the beautiful florentine vernacular into an artificial literary language without giving proper credit and praised to that spoken language which he also used and appreciated. 


Machiavelli's views emerge from his lifetime experiences of international ambassadors sent on several missions to several European powers, and his contact with intellectuals and politicians but also ordinary people with whom he spent  his most important moments of his life, first inside, and after the exile, outside Florence. 


The attitude of the renaissance man is as pragmatic in language as in politics, which in his opinion was the key to everything, and only italy's unification would solve the age-old question of which standard to choose, and make sure that everyone would conform to it. 


No providence ruled the world, and fortune was no longer the minister of God, as dante said, but a capricious whore who understood nothing but force: when Machiavelli talks about the eternal dilemma of virtue and fortune in his Prince he says that 


...la fortuna è donna; ed è necessario, volendola tenere sotto, batterla e urtarla. E si vede che si lascia più vincere da questi, che da quelli che freddamente procedono. 


E però sempre, come donna, è amica de' giovani, perché sono meno respettivi, più feroci, e con più audacia la comandano. ... 


tr.


...luck is female; and if you want to keep her under your yoke, you have to beat her. See how she is more easily conquered by these [men who treat her badly], than by those who treat her gently. 


And yet, being female, she seeks the company of young males, because they are tougher with her, more driven by passion, so that they master her more boldly. (The Prince, chap.XXV) 


The Renaissance redescovers the original Latin meaning of virtù (ability), ignored in the Middle Ages: virtù here menas the capacity to carry something to effect, whatever the means. In the above passage, feroce, "fierce" also regains its old Latin meaning of: 'impulsive, impetuous'. 

Ferocia is not necessarily evil: it is what we call "aggressive action", a self-preserving drive.

Machiavelli had an extensive knowledge of the classics and Roman History, and especially Titus Livius who largely inspired his Prince, a work in which he, based on the study of Roman History, explained his vision for unifying Italy: based on such convictions he epeatedly exorted Prince Borgia 'Vantentino' to carry out the unification process. Assassination was a small price compared to what was at stake, italy's future. 


Machiavelli's love for Latin loans must not lead us to think he was a something like a bookworm or a theorist. His attitude was similar to Lorenzo's love for blends of popular and scholarly terms: he was a practical man who wanted to hear this language spoken by Italians from all walks of life, not just the erudite, and continuously 'abused' his own language, eager as he was to experiment with it. 


His Italian standard should, most of all, be able to reach into the heart of the layman. As a Florentine Machiavelli was continually exposed to his dialect in which he was raised, and loved it, with a sympathy for the one spoken in the countryside rathern than the city. 


Remembering his native land and the simple people he befriended, he never forgot his native dialect. Could a volgare illustre contain the technical terms a worker needed for his daily chores? It could and it should, but it did not because Italian writers often looked to 'urbane' Florentine as the only basis for the Italian language. 


Surprisingly, this conviction was even more rooted in other Italian states than in Florence. Machiavelli appreciated the spontaneity of the rural language, both powerful and down-to-earth. He loved the countryside and did not mind going out on long walks hunting or fishing with friends or simply mixing with locals to play cards and drink wine and enjoying the occasional tavern brawl: 


Io mi sto in villa (...) ho insino a qui uccellato a' tordi di mia mano. Levàvomi innanzi dì, impaniavo, andavone oltre con un fascio di gabbie addosso, che parevo el Geta quando e' tornava dal porto con i libri di amphitrione: pigliavo almeno dua, al più sei tordi. E così stetti tutto settembre (...) Partitomi del bosco, io me ne vo a una fonte (...). Trasferiscomi poi in sulla strada, nell'osteria: parlo con quelli che passono, domando delle nuove de' paesi loro, intendo varie cose e noto varii gusti e diverse fantasie d'uomini. Viene in questo mentre l'ora del desinare; dove con la mia brigata mi mangio di quelli cibi che questa mia povera villa e pàululo patrimonio comporta. Mangiato che ho, ritorno nell'osteria. Quivi è l'oste, per l'ordinario, un beccaio, un mugnaio, due fornaciai. Con questi m'ingaglioffo per tutto dì, giocando a cricca, a trich-trach, e dove poi nascono mille contese e infiniti dispetti di parole iniuriose; e il più delle volte si combatte un quattrino, e siamo sentiti non di manco, gridare da San Casciano. Così, rinvolto intra questi pidocchi, traggo el cervello da muffa (...) (italics mine) 


tr.:


I live in the countryside (...) so far I've been hunting thrushes with my own hands. I used to get up before dawn, set the lime for the birds, going past the traps with such a bunch of cages on my back as to look like Getas when he came back from the port with Amphitrio's books on his back: and I usually caught a minimum of two , six thrushes at best. This was my life througout September (...). As I leave from the wood I walk to a spring (...). Then I get to the road and reach a tavern: I speak with passers-by, ask them for news, from where they come from, hear many novelties and make a note of those diverse tastes and different types of men. As I do that, it is lunch time already: now, surrounded by my friends I eat what food can be had in this poor countryside with what little money I can spare. After lunch, I head back to the tavern. Here I usually meet the host, a butcher, a miller and two bakers, and I have quarrels with them all day, playing three-of-a-kind, backgammon: and now when we get into endless fights and backbitings without no four-letter-words to spare; most of the time we fight for a pence, and we are heard shouting a long way from San Casciano. This way, soaking in that trash, I save my brain from rusting (...) 

(Letter dfrom Niccolò Machiavelli to Francesco Vettori in Rome) 

The passage refers to his exile in San Casciano, not far from Florence, where he retreated after being imprisoned and tortured by the Medicis after their return. Machiavelli had been employed as ambassador and cousellor by the these princes of Florence, but after the French had dethroned them he had also collaborated with the short-lived republic. 


When the Medicis returned, he offered his services to them, but they no longer trusted him. He was imprisoned, tortured and when released, was still unwelcome in the city, and had to go into exile. He hoped his friend Francesco Vettori among others might put in a good word for him so he could return to work for the Medicis. But they would no longer employ him. This devastated him more than anything in the world, and he ended his life haunted by regrets and the bitterness for not being able to serve his beloved Florence ever, again. 


It is likely a polite person like Bembo would not have appreciated some of the words I have in Machiavelli's passage: he was the kind of man who, when faced with choosing between 'get' and 'acquire' would have invariably crossed out the former on your paper and reproached you for using that, and never forgive you for using Scottish over British English. 


A few hundred miles from Florence, in the aristocratic Republic of Venice, the perception of Italian might change dramatically, and Bembo's pedantic views could hardly inspire a collection of sonnets like Petrarch's: at best, his excellent knowledge of literature might produce perfect but sterile imitations, and this is precisely what he did. 


Purists like Bembo admired Petrarch for the unique purity of his language: terse without being banal, beautiful and rich without using the four-letter words or those popular expressions that Dante and Boccaccio alternated to their polite, refined, and even complex sentences. Their virtue ws the ability to span between both sides of the sprectrum: but Bembo considered it a flaw, a weakness, and was looking for an artificial uniformity. 


In effect, even Dante was able to switch register though the model Italian he presents in his de Divina Eloquentia largely ignores his 'oversights' used to inveigh against the corrupted politicians and clergy who sentenced him and his friends to death, eventually forcing him into an exile which left him destitute and obliged to appeal to the compassion of princes like Cangrande della Scala. 


Bembo appreciated Boccaccio for inventing Italian prose, but, even more than Dante, Boccaccio has the ability of being direct and hitting on taboo subjects as eroticism, sex, brutal murders while still keeping an elegant, clear style, and this was what embarassed Bembo and his friends. Only Petrarch was fail-safe in every respect, Bembo's admiration for him was unconditional. 


Venice and the Purists 


Pietro Bembo (1470-1547), a Venetian who lived long in the Florence of Lorenzo Il Magnifico, represented the purist's view, not least, as we said, because he was from outside Florence. Like many Italians had made icons of Dante, Petrarch and Boccaccio: no language outside their books could be called Italian.

Bembo wanted to protect Florence's literary language from such contaminations as those 'suffered' at the hands of Venetian, but would not hear of any modern Florentine as well. The establishment of standard Italian marked, in fact, the birth of Florentine as a dialect of the Italian language, but one that had rusted in the books for to hundred years. 

In his Prose della volgar lingua (1525), a fictional dialogue (in three books) supposed to have taken place in Venice, in the home of his brother Carlo Bembo, Pietro tells a brief history of the Italian language, praising Petrarch, Dante and Boccaccio as models for all Italians (first book). 


He then proceeeds to analyse excerpts and poems from the three writers (second book); in the last he elaborates the ideal rules for an Italian grammar. He believes that only the Florentine language in its 'golden age' written by those authors could be the basis for a standard: his preference goes to Petrarch, followed by Boccaccio and Dante. 


Because of its perfection, their Italian would be unchangeable through time because no other future author could ever make better literature than these. Bembo's uncompromising view was also prompted by his fears about the increasing influence of his own dialect, Venetian, which was becoming more important given the great political power of the Republic of Venice in the 1500s. 


Ludovico Ariosto was one of Bembo's adimirers and his principles are reflected in his works. Besides writing the Orlando Furioso, a long narrative poem vaguely inspired by the deeds of the Chanson de Roland, he also wrote several comedies for the court of Ferrara. 

"He was the first in our literature to write commedie in vernacular modeled on those by Plautus and Terentius, and the first in the history of theatre to devise and build a self-sufficient scene", says Manacorda, reminding us of some of his greatest comedies: Cassaria, Suppositi,

Negromante, Lena and Studenti. 


The opinions of most Renaissance writers, though varied, fell within one spectrum. All of them agree on establishing norms that must generate a kind of 'ideal' language, from Machiavelli's municipal, to Castiglione's koinè of court vernaculars to Benbo's 1300s literary tradition, and despite their differences, a national will eventually be arrived at in this century. 


In the research for the perfect language, it is easy to feel the classical aura that surrounds the ideal cities painted and partly realised by the princes and their architects inspired by Vitruvius. Also, Utopians are widely acclaimed, whether their ideal is political (Thomas More) or architectural (Leon Battista Alberti) especially at a time where Plato's Repubblica enthralls politicians and philosophers. 


Perfection is what every man must aim for: Castiglione's Cortegiano must learn how to paint, play good music, sing melodiously, write poetry, dress according to a canon, even his behavior can be flawless if the reader will follow his precepts. But the real world was far from perfect, attempts to unified Italy failed, wars devasted the peninsula and the sack of Rome by Charles V's Landsnechts spread black death in Italy (1527). 


Paradoxically, all renaissance writers, as transpires from Machiavelli's letter, live in both worlds: the real one during the day, made of feudal strife, war, and famine, and an ideal one in their libraries, somehow combining both. They lived in real cities but dreamed of virtual cities, they were making a brand new world of technological marvels but admired unconditionally the classical world.


There was a strange connivence between magic and science in the most brilliant scientists, and it was much easier to be burned at the stake for sorcery than it was in the middle ages (only Galilei will explain with precision what science is and what it is not in the following century). 

Despite the paradox, harmony is what intellectuals believe in. For this they looked at Imperial Rome and especially the Age of Augustus and the great poets of that time (Orace, Virgil). 

The Outsider: Pietro Aretino 


For all the attempts to legislate over the Italian language, there was one loud voice outside the choir, a true rebel who did not subscribe to any of the ideas of the Renaissance scholars and widely anticipated many Baroque authors with his love of linguistic eccess, the use of personal neologisms and other caprices. 


Pietro Aretino may be considered Bembo's poetic nemesis: he became famous on account of his erotic poems and Tracts (Sonetti Lussuriosi, 1526, Ragionamenti or Sei Giornate, 1534-6). His realistic vein of the Sonnets bordering on porn looks like a parody of Bembo's Canzoniere (inspired by the pious Petrarch), while in his Sei Giornate (1534-6) an old woman teaches a young girl how to become a prostitute. 


His mercilessly satiric verse addressed to Kings and Princes, and his friendship with Cosimo I of Florence and his influential father earned him respect and was looked in awe even in Venice, home of Bembo himself. Holy Roman Emperor Charles V sent him quite a few gifts only to be spared his ironic verse which Aretino used to mail to the courts without notice for the unique pleasure of embarassing them. 


However, it would be unfair to say that his literary success was due to his political influence and blackmail. Aretino's poetry and drama is powerful and shows remarkable skill and versatility in all genres: contrary to the trend of his own age, he opposed a literature that tried to imitate the classics, and only trusted his own instinct. 


He rejected tradition in the name of originality whether that be or not be at the expense of decorum and religion. His phrase is already baroque in his irregular turns and twists, hyperboles, and use of extravagant language. 


Bembo's Radical Solution 


Pietro Bembo's plan was not just about Florentine purism: he intended to perfect the language through Latin and Greek calques. His uncompromising stand may seem radical, but as such it could evade the stumbling block of the partisan feuds over dialect imports. 


His views eventually prevailed, leading to an established standard sooner than it might be hoped for. He also modeled the Italian period on Cicero, whose work is one of the best examples of literary latin free from popular influence. 


Bembo's choice reflects a timeless, static view of language, whose virtue lies in its ability to resist change, not to adapt to it. Such stability is possible, says Bembo, when a language is built on the works of the greatest, immortal authors. 


According to his theory, the linguistic influence of Dante will continue to be felt, since his Commedia will always be read, and in a sense, will always be modern. 

Corruption and change are the whim of popular language, which is not dependent on written sources, he said. Such is the also position endorsed by Ludovico Ariosto and Torquato Tasso. 
The Power of the Aldine Press 


Though Manutius' printing press was sensitive to this issue, commercial interest, especially in the Republic of Venice, pushed in different directions. 


The Aldine Press printed as much as 80% of texts in Italian, but the rest of its efforts were spent on printing Latin and Greek classics with authoritative commmentaries and philological notes by eminent such scholars as Erasmus. Manutius, Bembo, the humanists working at the Aldine Press brought their favorite classic literature to bear on the linguistic debate about the Italian language. 


The Florentines were well aware that their language had changed since Dante had started to pen down his Commedia, and how damaging it was to try freeze it into some ideal, static model. But it was the Venetians who printed most of the books, and merchants from Tuscany could either print fewer copies of the greatest works and had to content themselves with more popular books that could be sold easily. 


Indeed, it was difficult for people not born and raised in Florence to grasp the beauty and richness of popular Florentine, which might be used for comedy, burlesque poetry, satire or simply reproduce the colorful accents of present-day life. But the economic power of Venice) had the upper hand. 


The rediscovery of Latin led at least to the introduction of more words into spoken Italian; from there they passed into other European languages, sometimes via French, sometimes they came staight from Italy. 


We have seen how Lat. machina had evolved from the meaning of 'machine' into it. macina (mill). Now the original word machina was reintroduced in its original sense of 'machine' by restoring the old H. Also, an unprecedented number of scientific terms were coined, most of those related to medicine date to the 1500s. 


Manutius, Bembo and 'new' coins from Latin 


This new 'Latinisation' received a strong impulse from the introduction of the press since scholars like Bembo and Erasmus collaborated with Manuzio to print the critical editions of a large number of Greek and Latin classics.

Aldo Manuzio was not just a printer, he was also an accomplished philologist who worked with Bembo. He prepared a special edition of Petrarch's songs from an original manuscript, that bore Petrarch's initials. More Latin words introduced by the press were: assioma, [en. axiom] circonflesso [en. circumflex ], circospezione [en. circumspection], clinica [en. clinic], comparabile [en. comparable], congenito [en. congenitus], dialetto [en. dialect], ecatombe [en.hecatomb], eccentrico [en. eccentric], peninsola [en. peninsula], omonimo [en. homonym], preferire [en. prefer], scenografia [en. scenography], trilingue [en. trilingual], utero [en. uterus] 

Italian terms coined from Vitruvius 


Almost all of the words used in architecture were taken from Vitruvius, as scenografia [see above list], simmetria [symmetry] or vestibolo [en. vestibule]. 


The same applied to maths and astronomy. Most of the new words passed into English when humanists like Giovanni Florio moved to England to teach Italian or Latin to the local aristocracy. 


A certain interest of Elizabethan England in the italian language transpires in some of his major works, such as the First Fruites (1578), The Second Fruites (1591) (two famous Italian grammars) and one English-Italian dictionary called A Worlde of Wordes (1598). As an enthusiast of renaissance drama, Queen Elizabeth I appreciated the Italian Renaissance and apparently spoke Italian flawlessly. 


The literary contribution of Italian dramatists and comedians to the Elizabethan Theatre (many Italian companies were in London in the 1590s and may have provided another channel for Italian and Latin loans) was essential. 


Spelling Problems 


While many of the new words survive in their original Latin or Greek form in English, a language that has no trouble pronouncing consonant clusters as -pt-, -ct- or -x-, in Italy such letters had to be assimilated to /tt/ or /ss/, /s/. Compare it. azione with English 'action', or It. essempio (later, esempio) with English 'example'.

However, many Italian writers kept swingin beteen forms for two more centuries (however, purists preferred the latin consonants clusters, and keeping the Hs in words like homo, honesto). Other spelling disagreements would persist, concerning for example, the use of ss instead of s. 

Though the Italian was mostly influenced by Florentine, differences between Florence's model, and the Northern and Southern varieties were still sensible even to scholars. The end of the century sees the foundation of the Accademia della Crusca by Lionardo Salviati (1583) to protect the purist standards propounded by Bembo. 


But as in politics, the struggles would continue in th bickering over terms adapted from vernacular and the 'lower' arts and crafts, an issue on which the Crusca was even less prone to concessions than bembo himself.