The 16th Century: the Renaissance
Bembo's New
Standard
When a linguistic unification
is achieved, political consolidation often follows. But the Italians,
who were on the whole, whether willingly or not, divided by foreign
powers who extended their political influence
throughout the peninsula, would or could not settle their differences
and the feuds between powerful local families usually ended in
violence.
Feelings ran high even between jealous siblings whom enemies knew how
to pit against one other.
Because of such partisanism, even linguistic
consolidation could not achieved without difficulties, on account of
the same rivalries that divided the courts politically. Though scholars
like Castiglione and Trissino, quoting Dante, defended the dignity of
the language spoken at court, claiming that a national standard should
be the equal sum of regional varieties rather than predominantly
Florentine and praised the dignity of Italian.
Castiglione and Trissino's school was aptly called the Courtisan
Tradition and is explained in the former's masterpiece, Il Cortegiano
(1528),
soon to be followed by Giangiorgio Trissino's Castellano (1529)
which
supported Castiglione's theories.
The theory earned a certain
reputation, but regional jealousies could hardly lead to a consensus.
A compromise between dialects was all but impossible as each
prince pretended to impose his own over the others, while the
Florentines, given their literary tradition would not accept
'corruptions' from the outside.
And yet not not a few Italians felt a common
language was necessary, not least merchants who had to compile
glossaries of different dialects even for minor business trips within
Italy. Hoping to reach a solution, Machiavelli defended the rural or
vernacular Florentine as opposed to the high standard of Dante,
Boccaccio
and Petrarch.
Machiavelli's Rural
Florentine: the Municipal Tradition
Italian
seems to develop after the success of purist view, (Dante, Petrarch and
Boccaccio'a literary language should be the canon). Such party is
probably responsible
for the coinage of many new words of classical origin while those from
dialect (spoken
Florentine) sometimes take new meanings.
Machiavelli's position is openly municipal: he puts more value
in
the colloquial Florentine spoken at his time and excludes any literary
or archaic language from the past. In the appendix to his Clizia, one
of his comedies, he expounds his ideas in an imaginary conversation
between him and Dante.
Here, il Sommo Poeta is made to sound like a snob and
hypocrite,
since machiavelli accuses him of having perverted the beautiful
florentine vernacular into an artificial literary language without
giving proper credit and praised to that spoken language which he also
used and appreciated.
Machiavelli's views emerge from his lifetime experiences of
international ambassadors sent on several missions to several European
powers, and his contact with intellectuals and politicians but also
ordinary people with whom he spent his most important moments
of
his life, first inside, and after the exile, outside Florence.
The attitude of the renaissance man is as pragmatic in
language as
in politics, which in his opinion was the key to everything, and only
italy's unification would solve the age-old question of which standard
to choose, and make sure that everyone would conform to it.
No providence ruled the world, and fortune was no longer the
minister of God, as dante said, but a capricious whore who understood
nothing but force: when Machiavelli
talks about the eternal dilemma of virtue and fortune in his Prince he
says that
...la fortuna è donna; ed è necessario,
volendola tenere
sotto, batterla e urtarla. E si vede che si lascia più
vincere
da questi, che da quelli che freddamente procedono.
E però
sempre, come donna, è amica de' giovani, perché
sono meno
respettivi, più feroci, e con più audacia la
comandano.
...
tr.
...luck is female; and if you want to keep her under your yoke,
you
have to beat her. See how she is more easily conquered by these [men
who treat her badly], than by those who treat her gently.
And yet,
being female, she seeks the company of young males, because they are
tougher with her, more driven by passion, so that they master her more
boldly. (The Prince, chap.XXV)
The Renaissance redescovers the original
Latin meaning of virtù (ability), ignored in the Middle
Ages:
virtù here menas the capacity to carry something to effect,
whatever the means. In the above passage, feroce, "fierce" also regains
its
old Latin meaning of: 'impulsive, impetuous'.
Ferocia is not
necessarily evil: it is what we call "aggressive action", a
self-preserving drive.
Machiavelli had an extensive knowledge of the
classics and Roman History, and especially Titus Livius who largely
inspired his Prince, a work in which he, based on the study of Roman
History, explained his vision for unifying Italy: based on such
convictions he epeatedly exorted Prince
Borgia 'Vantentino' to carry out the unification process. Assassination
was a small price compared to what was at stake, italy's
future.
Machiavelli's love for Latin loans
must not lead us to think he was a something like a bookworm or a
theorist. His attitude was similar to
Lorenzo's love for blends of popular and scholarly terms: he was a
practical man who wanted to hear this language spoken by Italians from
all walks of life, not just the erudite, and continuously 'abused' his
own language, eager as he was to experiment with it.
His Italian standard should, most of
all, be able to reach into the heart of the layman. As a Florentine
Machiavelli was continually exposed to his dialect in which he was
raised, and loved it, with a sympathy for the one spoken in the
countryside rathern than the city.
Remembering his native land and the simple people he
befriended, he
never forgot his native dialect. Could a volgare illustre contain the
technical terms a worker needed for his daily chores? It could and it
should, but it did not because Italian writers often looked to
'urbane' Florentine as the only basis for the Italian
language.
Surprisingly, this conviction was even more rooted in other
Italian
states than in Florence. Machiavelli appreciated the spontaneity of the
rural language, both powerful and down-to-earth. He loved the
countryside and did not mind going out on long walks hunting or fishing
with friends or simply mixing with locals to play cards and drink wine
and enjoying the occasional tavern brawl:
Io mi sto in villa (...) ho
insino a qui uccellato a' tordi di mia mano. Levàvomi
innanzi
dì, impaniavo, andavone oltre con un fascio di gabbie
addosso,
che parevo el Geta quando e' tornava dal porto con i libri di
amphitrione: pigliavo almeno dua, al più sei tordi. E
così stetti tutto settembre (...) Partitomi del bosco, io me
ne
vo a una fonte (...). Trasferiscomi poi in sulla strada, nell'osteria:
parlo con quelli che passono, domando delle nuove de' paesi loro,
intendo varie cose e noto varii gusti e diverse fantasie d'uomini.
Viene in questo mentre l'ora del desinare; dove con la mia brigata mi
mangio di quelli cibi che questa mia povera villa e pàululo
patrimonio comporta. Mangiato che ho, ritorno nell'osteria. Quivi
è l'oste, per l'ordinario, un beccaio, un mugnaio, due
fornaciai. Con questi m'ingaglioffo per tutto dì, giocando a
cricca, a trich-trach, e dove poi nascono mille contese e infiniti
dispetti di parole iniuriose; e il più delle volte si
combatte
un quattrino, e siamo sentiti non di manco, gridare da San Casciano.
Così, rinvolto intra questi pidocchi, traggo el cervello da
muffa (...) (italics mine)
tr.:
I live in the countryside (...) so far I've
been hunting thrushes with my own hands. I used to get up before dawn,
set the lime for the birds, going past the traps with such a bunch of
cages on my back as to look like Getas when he came back from the port
with Amphitrio's books on his back: and I usually caught a minimum of
two , six thrushes at best. This was my life througout September (...).
As I leave from the wood I walk to a spring (...). Then I get to the
road and reach a tavern: I speak with passers-by, ask them for news,
from where they come from, hear many novelties and make a note of those
diverse tastes and different types of men. As I do that, it is lunch
time already: now, surrounded by my friends I eat what food can be had
in this poor countryside with what little money I can spare. After
lunch, I head back to the tavern. Here I usually meet the host, a
butcher, a miller and two bakers, and I have quarrels with them all
day,
playing three-of-a-kind, backgammon: and now when we get into endless
fights and backbitings without no four-letter-words to spare; most of
the
time we fight for a pence, and we are heard shouting a long way from
San Casciano. This way, soaking in that trash, I save my brain from
rusting (...)
(Letter dfrom Niccolò Machiavelli to Francesco
Vettori in Rome)
The passage refers to his exile in San Casciano, not far from
Florence,
where he retreated after being imprisoned and tortured by the Medicis
after their return. Machiavelli had been employed as ambassador
and cousellor by the these princes of Florence, but after the French
had
dethroned them he had also collaborated with the short-lived
republic.
When
the Medicis returned, he offered his services to them, but they no
longer trusted him. He was imprisoned, tortured and when
released, was still unwelcome in the city, and had to go into
exile.
He hoped his friend Francesco Vettori among others might put in a good
word for
him so he could return to work for the Medicis. But they would no
longer
employ him. This devastated him more than anything in the world, and he
ended his life haunted by regrets and the bitterness for not being able
to serve his beloved Florence ever, again.
It is likely a polite person like Bembo would not have
appreciated
some of the words I have in Machiavelli's passage: he was the kind of
man who, when faced with
choosing between 'get' and 'acquire' would have invariably crossed out
the former
on your paper and reproached you for using that, and never forgive you
for using Scottish over British English.
A few hundred miles from Florence, in the aristocratic
Republic of
Venice, the perception of Italian might change dramatically, and
Bembo's pedantic views could hardly inspire a collection of sonnets
like Petrarch's: at best, his excellent knowledge of literature might
produce perfect but sterile imitations, and this is precisely
what
he did.
Purists like Bembo admired Petrarch for the unique purity of
his
language: terse without being banal, beautiful and rich without using
the four-letter words or those popular expressions that Dante and
Boccaccio alternated to their polite, refined, and even complex
sentences. Their virtue ws the ability to span between both sides of
the sprectrum: but Bembo considered it a flaw, a weakness, and was
looking for an artificial uniformity.
In effect, even Dante was able to
switch register though the model Italian he presents
in his de Divina Eloquentia largely ignores his 'oversights' used to
inveigh against the corrupted politicians and clergy who sentenced him
and his friends to
death, eventually forcing him into an exile which left him destitute
and obliged to appeal to the compassion of princes like Cangrande della
Scala.
Bembo appreciated Boccaccio for
inventing Italian prose, but, even more than Dante, Boccaccio has
the ability of being direct and hitting on taboo
subjects as eroticism, sex, brutal murders while still keeping an
elegant, clear style, and this was what embarassed Bembo and his
friends. Only Petrarch was fail-safe in every respect,
Bembo's admiration for him was unconditional.
Venice and the Purists
Pietro Bembo (1470-1547), a Venetian who lived long in the
Florence of
Lorenzo Il Magnifico, represented the purist's view, not least, as we
said, because he was from outside Florence. Like many Italians
had made
icons of Dante, Petrarch and Boccaccio: no language outside their books
could be called Italian.
Bembo wanted to protect Florence's literary
language from such contaminations as those 'suffered' at the hands of
Venetian, but would not hear of any modern Florentine as well. The
establishment of standard Italian marked, in fact, the birth of
Florentine as a dialect of the Italian language, but one that had
rusted in the books for to hundred years.
In his Prose
della
volgar lingua (1525), a fictional dialogue (in three
books) supposed to
have taken place in Venice, in the home of his brother Carlo Bembo,
Pietro tells a brief history of the Italian language, praising
Petrarch, Dante and Boccaccio as models for all Italians (first
book).
He then proceeeds to analyse excerpts and poems from the three
writers
(second book); in the last he elaborates the ideal rules for an Italian
grammar. He believes that only the Florentine language in its 'golden
age' written by those authors could be the basis for a standard: his
preference goes to Petrarch, followed by Boccaccio and Dante.
Because
of its perfection, their Italian would be unchangeable through time
because no other future author could ever make better literature than
these. Bembo's uncompromising view was also prompted by his fears about
the increasing influence of his own dialect, Venetian, which was
becoming more important given the great political power of the Republic
of Venice in the 1500s.
Ludovico Ariosto was one of Bembo's adimirers and his
principles are
reflected in his works. Besides writing the Orlando Furioso, a long
narrative poem vaguely inspired by the deeds of the Chanson de Roland,
he also wrote several comedies for the court of Ferrara.
"He was the first in our literature to
write commedie in vernacular modeled on those by Plautus and
Terentius, and the first in the history of theatre to devise
and
build a self-sufficient scene", says Manacorda, reminding us of some of
his greatest comedies: Cassaria, Suppositi,
Negromante, Lena and
Studenti.
The opinions of most Renaissance writers, though varied, fell
within one spectrum. All of them agree on establishing norms that must
generate a kind of 'ideal' language, from Machiavelli's municipal, to
Castiglione's koinè of court vernaculars to
Benbo's 1300s literary tradition, and despite their differences, a
national will eventually be arrived at in this century.
In the research for the perfect language, it is easy to feel
the classical aura that
surrounds the ideal cities painted and partly realised by the princes
and their architects inspired by Vitruvius. Also, Utopians
are widely acclaimed, whether their ideal is political (Thomas More) or
architectural (Leon Battista Alberti) especially at a time where
Plato's Repubblica enthralls politicians and philosophers.
Perfection
is what every man must aim for: Castiglione's Cortegiano must learn how
to paint,
play good music, sing melodiously, write poetry, dress according
to a canon, even his behavior can be flawless if the reader will follow
his precepts. But the real world was far from perfect, attempts to
unified Italy failed, wars devasted the peninsula and the sack of Rome
by Charles V's Landsnechts spread black death in Italy (1527).
Paradoxically, all renaissance writers, as transpires from
Machiavelli's letter, live in both worlds: the real one during the day,
made of feudal strife, war, and famine, and an ideal one in their
libraries, somehow combining both. They lived in real cities but
dreamed of virtual cities, they were making a brand new world of
technological marvels but admired unconditionally the classical world.
There was a strange connivence between magic and
science in the most brilliant scientists, and it was much easier to be
burned at the stake for sorcery than it was in the middle ages (only
Galilei will
explain with precision what science is and what it is not in the
following century).
Despite the paradox, harmony is what intellectuals believe
in. For this they looked at Imperial Rome and especially the Age of
Augustus and the great poets of that time (Orace, Virgil).
The Outsider: Pietro Aretino
For all the attempts to legislate over the Italian language,
there was one
loud voice outside the choir, a true rebel who did not subscribe to any
of the ideas of the Renaissance scholars and widely anticipated many
Baroque authors with his love of linguistic eccess, the use of personal
neologisms and other caprices.
Pietro Aretino may be considered Bembo's poetic
nemesis: he became famous on account of his erotic poems and Tracts
(Sonetti Lussuriosi, 1526, Ragionamenti or Sei Giornate, 1534-6). His
realistic vein of the Sonnets bordering on porn looks like a parody of
Bembo's Canzoniere (inspired by the pious Petrarch), while in his Sei
Giornate
(1534-6) an old woman teaches a young girl how to become a
prostitute.
His mercilessly satiric verse addressed to Kings and Princes,
and his
friendship with Cosimo I of Florence and his influential father earned
him respect and was looked in awe even in Venice, home of
Bembo himself. Holy Roman Emperor
Charles V sent him quite a few gifts only to be spared his ironic
verse which Aretino used to mail to the courts without notice for the
unique pleasure of embarassing them.
However, it would be
unfair to say that his literary success was due to his political
influence and blackmail.
Aretino's poetry and drama is powerful and shows remarkable skill and
versatility in all genres: contrary to the trend of his own age, he
opposed a literature that tried to imitate the classics, and only
trusted his own instinct.
He rejected tradition in the name of
originality whether that be or not be at the expense of decorum and
religion. His phrase is already baroque in his irregular turns and
twists, hyperboles, and use of extravagant language.
Bembo's Radical
Solution
Pietro Bembo's plan was not just about Florentine purism: he
intended to perfect the language through Latin and Greek
calques. His
uncompromising stand may seem radical, but as such it could evade the
stumbling block of the partisan feuds over dialect imports.
His views
eventually prevailed, leading to an established standard sooner than it
might be hoped for. He also modeled the Italian period on Cicero, whose
work is one of the best examples of literary latin free from popular
influence.
Bembo's choice reflects a timeless, static view of language,
whose virtue lies in its ability to resist change, not to adapt to it.
Such stability is possible, says Bembo, when a language is built on the
works of the greatest, immortal authors.
According to his theory, the
linguistic influence of Dante will continue to be felt, since his
Commedia will always be read, and in a sense, will always be
modern.
Corruption and change are the whim of
popular language, which is not dependent on written sources, he said.
Such is the also position endorsed by Ludovico Ariosto and Torquato
Tasso.
The Power of the Aldine Press
Though Manutius' printing press
was sensitive to this issue, commercial interest, especially
in the
Republic of Venice, pushed in different directions.
The Aldine Press
printed as much as 80% of texts in Italian, but the rest of its efforts
were spent on printing Latin and Greek classics with authoritative
commmentaries and philological notes by eminent such scholars as
Erasmus. Manutius, Bembo, the humanists working at the Aldine Press
brought their favorite classic literature to bear on the linguistic
debate about
the Italian language.
The Florentines were well aware that their
language had changed since Dante had started to pen down his Commedia,
and
how damaging it was to try freeze it into some ideal, static model. But
it was the Venetians who printed most of the books, and merchants from
Tuscany could either print fewer copies of the greatest works and had
to content themselves with more popular books that could be sold
easily.
Indeed, it was difficult for people not born and raised in
Florence to grasp the beauty and richness of popular Florentine, which
might be used for comedy, burlesque poetry, satire or simply reproduce
the colorful accents of present-day life. But the economic power of
Venice) had the upper hand.
The
rediscovery of Latin led at least to the introduction of more words
into spoken Italian; from there they passed into other European
languages, sometimes via French, sometimes they came staight from
Italy.
We have seen how Lat. machina had evolved
from the meaning of 'machine' into it. macina (mill). Now the original
word machina
was reintroduced in its original sense of 'machine' by
restoring the
old H. Also, an unprecedented number of scientific terms were coined,
most of those related to medicine date to the 1500s.
Manutius,
Bembo and 'new' coins from Latin
This new 'Latinisation' received a
strong impulse from the introduction of the press since scholars like
Bembo and Erasmus collaborated with Manuzio to print the critical
editions of a large number of Greek and Latin classics.
Aldo Manuzio
was not just a printer, he was also an accomplished philologist who
worked with Bembo. He prepared a special edition of Petrarch's songs
from an original manuscript, that bore Petrarch's initials. More Latin
words introduced by the press were: assioma, [en. axiom] circonflesso
[en. circumflex ], circospezione [en. circumspection], clinica [en.
clinic], comparabile [en. comparable], congenito [en. congenitus],
dialetto [en. dialect], ecatombe [en.hecatomb], eccentrico [en.
eccentric], peninsola [en. peninsula], omonimo [en. homonym], preferire
[en. prefer], scenografia [en. scenography], trilingue [en.
trilingual], utero [en. uterus]
Italian terms coined from Vitruvius
Almost all of the words used in architecture were taken from
Vitruvius,
as scenografia [see above list], simmetria [symmetry] or vestibolo [en.
vestibule].
The same applied to maths and astronomy. Most of the new words
passed into English when
humanists like Giovanni Florio moved to England to teach Italian or
Latin to
the local aristocracy.
A certain interest of Elizabethan England in the italian
language transpires
in some of his major works, such as the First Fruites (1578), The
Second Fruites (1591) (two famous Italian grammars) and one
English-Italian dictionary called A Worlde of Wordes (1598). As an
enthusiast of renaissance drama, Queen
Elizabeth I appreciated the Italian Renaissance and apparently spoke
Italian flawlessly.
The literary contribution of Italian
dramatists and comedians to the Elizabethan Theatre (many Italian
companies were in London in the 1590s and may have provided another
channel for Italian and Latin loans) was essential.
Spelling Problems
While many of
the new words survive in their original Latin or Greek form in English,
a
language that has no trouble pronouncing consonant clusters as -pt-,
-ct- or -x-, in Italy such letters had to be assimilated to /tt/ or
/ss/, /s/. Compare it. azione
with English 'action', or It. essempio
(later, esempio) with English 'example'.
However, many Italian writers
kept swingin beteen forms for two more centuries
(however, purists preferred the latin consonants clusters, and keeping
the Hs
in words like homo, honesto). Other spelling disagreements would
persist,
concerning for example, the use of ss instead of s.
Though the Italian
was mostly influenced by Florentine, differences between Florence's
model, and the Northern and Southern varieties were still sensible even
to scholars. The end of the century sees the foundation of the
Accademia della Crusca by Lionardo Salviati (1583) to protect the
purist standards propounded by Bembo.
But as in politics, the struggles
would continue in th bickering over terms adapted from
vernacular and the 'lower' arts and crafts, an issue on which the
Crusca was even less prone to concessions than bembo himself.